Monday, August 18, 2008
BootRap Podcast: Bootstrap Film Fest
Sunday, August 17, 2008
Entrepreneurs and Intellectual Property
Boy, this ones going to get me in trouble - but here we go.
IP ain't worth crap.
I just finished a bunch of work-arounds, that is I looked at several different patents and for each figured a way to do the same thing that didn't violate the original patent's claims. In a couple of them I came up with novel and unique ways to do the same thing that weren't covered so I created new IP. In effect I rendered the original patents useless. So with guys like me around what good are patents, especially to the entrepreneur?
In fact they have tremendous value, but not as patents. The most powerful patent is a Provisional Patent. Provisionals are vague and indeterminate; no one gets to see them (unless you are so foolish as to show them to someone, in which case you deserve what you get) so no one knows what you are doing. You have a year to turn them into a real patent so you can say patent pending immediately on your product or process and even I can't do a work-around because you have not been granted any claims for me to work with. After you file no one really knows what claims the USPTO will give you, and your original claims may be modified, so it is still a minefield.
Patents take years to be granted, you can hassle with office actions for 4 or 5 years if you want (look up submarine patents (nothing to do with underwater boats)). If you are an entrepreneur in a hot field the real value, by the time you get the claims granted the technology or process will probably have been obsoleted by the market and not used in your product anyway.
IP does impress investors, gives them lots of security. IP impresses corporate folks because they live in fear anyway. IP impresses acquisition folks, IP is a great vanity device, for you personally and the company in general. IP's value is intellectual and emotional security more than technological reality. It gives you an asset out of nothing in the early stages of your business. It is a rallying point for everyone who doesn't understand its reality.
This truth should give you confidence. It's like the Emperor's Clothes, knowing truth you can then use it to your advantage and not be taken in by others.
Oh yeah, watch out for all those patent professionals and consultants, their views are self motivated, use them to your drive your goals but don't be taken in. You and your patent attorney must scheme to use everyone else's beliefs to your end. It's the idea of the IP that's what makes it so valuable. Like most things, it's the illusion as it appears in everyone else's mind that is the real power.
copyright Barry W Thornton 2008 all rights reserved
Thursday, August 14, 2008
Thinking Outside The Box - There Is No Spoon, And There Isn't A Box Either
The idea of Celeb 4 A Day began years ago when I was at photography school (a very serious school with very serious future/career promises). The thought occurred to me at that time that as celebrity obsession grew, there were sure to be people that wondered what it was like to actually BE famous. In fact, I was pretty sure that's where all this celebrity obsession (not to mention people becoming actual celebrities) was coming from in the first place.
I thought it was a great idea, but I was at school - life was happening. And so that idea, like a few others I have, was stored away into the furthest recesses of my mind as I went about finishing school, moving from Santa Barbara back to Austin, finding design and photography work, in general trying to accomplish those pre-set goals (boxes) that I had learned and created for myself.
Fast forward to five years later, November 2007; I'm taking a break from my daily design grind (including the BD Tech Daily, ha!), listening to some great tunes and wondering what I should do with my lunch break. My thoughts pretty much went like this:
"Well, Tania, you've designed fliers, brochures, collateral, magazines, but you've never designed a website. I wonder if you could do that."
"Let's see, what would be a fun thing to work on to test your design skills? Something that has no real deadline and isn't something that is so serious that the world as we know it would end if it turns out that you suck at web design."
Insert picture of me staring at a blank screen here.
"Oh, I know! How about that crazy idea you had in school about providing people with...let's see...what should we call it? Personal Paparazzi!"
Two hours later I had created a name, a website and had thought through and posted to the site 3 different packages that I could provide people with. What now? Well, I called a few friends ("Oh, how nice. That's cute.") and was just happy to have produced something that was online and looked pretty good. I had no plans to build a business on this, no idea if anything would ever come of it - I was content to have just made something out of an idea. I spent a total of $10 on my "test of skills." And to this day, that's about what I've spent on actual marketing.
What happened next taught me that even though I had no idea what I was doing - no real plan, no real path, no intricately designed goals for the future of this product - that not knowing what you are doing, but just taking action and doing something, is where the magic really happens.
Two weeks after I launched the Celeb 4 A Day site, Time Magazine called to say they had Googled 'personal paparazzi' out of curiosity and wanted to do a story on the company. A month later, The Today Show was in my living room interviewing me. I used that coverage in those following months to bootstrap even more coverage on the radio, local and international news outlets, and eventually was even flown to New York to be on the Rachael Ray Show. Do I have a degree in PR or marketing? Nope. I pretty much just used the same principles as I established that one day at lunch: do what I could and not necessarily what I knew how to do (in the media's case it was to send out previous coverage via email suggesting they might like to be in on the action too - hey, it was cheap and it worked!).
Here I am now, a few months shy of Celeb 4 A Day's one year anniversary, and I've got virtual offices in Austin, Los Angeles, San Francisco and New York with more expansion plans (slowly, I say, slowly) in the future. I've redesigned the website, added some really exciting packages including an all-inclusive paparazzi vacation, and I'm currently in talks with a major television network to star in a reality show based on my life and my company. The company itself is growing remarkably and we are getting busier and busier (happily, lunch breaks are pretty much out of the question now).
Have I made mistakes? Sure. But, better than that I still don't know what I'm doing. To be clear, what that means to me is that I do not have some big white board hanging above my life with an exact outline of what I should do, what direction I absolutely have to take, or even where I'll be in the coming months. I have no box inside of which all things must lie, function or even make sense. If I had limited myself - and the company - to that box, I wouldn't have been open to all the exciting adventures and possibilities that have arisen since last November.
Although I could tell you about things like how everything I've experienced and learned has brought me to where I am today, how to talk/deal with the media and go into various details of my business, the Bootstrap Blog is only so long...so, for now, let me just reiterate the point I'm trying to make here today:
Don't try to convince yourself to "Think Outside The Box," because by default you are creating a box for yourself by admitting that it exists. There isn't a box. There is only the Right Action at the Right Time and anything beyond that limits you solely to the paths that you create for yourself and you miss out on all the unknown possibilities.
Tania Cowher is the owner of Celeb 4 A Day, providing the every day person with their very own personal paparazzi experience. Currently, she enjoys walking with her dogs, running the company and watching really bad reality television - which she justifies to her bewildered husband as "research."
BootRap Podcast of David Galenson
Monday, August 11, 2008
Turn Right to Go Left
Hmmm, that's an odd piece of advice, isn't it?
As I think back on my own entrepreneurial journey, I can tell you that I've always focused a lot of energy on my current business pursuits, thinking that if I could pour myself into it, I'd reap the rewards and then when it's over...adjust my life back to a state of "normalcy". Things like exercise, hobbies, and community have often been sidelined as a result. While I sometimes won the battle, I invariably saw myself in the end...losing the war.
For many of us who are running a business, the list of tasks is quite literally endless. There's hiring, firing, marketing, selling, negotiating, creating, managing, paying, developing and thinking going on all the time. We're constantly challenged with focusing on what's most important on a weekly or even daily basis. Stack into the equation...kids, mortgage, bills, debt, health issues, obligations, etc and the nice box that we've created around life begins to crack.
After hearing the advice from Doc, Lighting tries the maneuver, knowing full well the old man doesn't know what he's talking about and with a lack of faith, he ends up crashing.
Why is it that life seems to be so challenging sometimes, especially as an entrepreneur? Through a series of experiences in my own life including always striving to achieve more to the point of breakdown, coming to faith in Christ, having kids, and birthing a new startup, the box has officially been cracked wide open.
However...now, at the age of 35, with a family of 5 and an Internet startup in full swing, I have more going on than ever before, but the strange part is that I'm experiencing greater productivity, more joy and stronger business insight through...are you ready for this?
Letting go.
Part of this change started during a powerful event 2 months ago. Brett Hurt of Bazaarvoice, Leadership Austin and Bootstrap, sponsored a leadership presentation with Stew Friedman, author, speaker, and professor at the Wharton School of Business. Stew described a transformational way of thinking called Total Leadership, which can be used to become a better leader and have a richer life. Friedman describes the 4 domains of life as Self, Family, Work, and Community.
Part of the process involves creating "experiments", that challenge the way we're doing life and by measuring the results, better align what we do with what we value most in life. What do you value? For me, I value spending quality time with my wife and kids, leading other men in the way of Christ and exercising/mountain biking. What I began to learn was that pursuing these desires WHILE building my business has allowed me to stop chasing life and start living it. I work out just about everyday, spend great time with my kids and wife, and am in a life giving discipleship group.
Do I still get caught in the trap of thinking, "if I just work harder on my business, then I'll find success"? Well, the answer is Yes. But I know now more than ever that real productivity and success comes when I pursue what I say I value most. Plus, I'm finding a greater ability to keep objective about where my business is going...by taking time to actually step away from the business.
It seems counter to think about spending less time on your business to actually become more successful, but the experiment is proving correct that if you want to go left, sometimes you need to turn right.
In the final scenes, while competing in the biggest race of his life, Lighting has the trust to let go and choose Doc's advice...and in the end, he's able to not only get back on the racetrack saving precious time, but go on to even greater glory.
Damon Flowers lives his life as a husband and father of 3, is an active Christ follower at Gateway Church and the Co-Founder of Dwellgo.com, a social community best described as online dating for Real Estate, which is being piloted in Austin. He leads the Bootstrap Real Estate Subgroup.
Wednesday, August 06, 2008
The value of the answer is directly proportional to the quality of the question
Examples of questions that beg questions in response:
I need software for online collaboration
- What do you mean by "collaboration" ?
- Are all users in one org ? LAN or Web ?
- Is security a key issue ?
- Do you have a budget or really need something free ?
- What is the form of the entity?
- What is the nature of the business?
- Is the business revenue in the range of $0-2 million, or more like $20 million?
- Is this for general accounting and tax matters, or is there some major issue at hand?
I grapple with this issue frequently in intellectual property questions because that is an area in which I have background and in which I frequently respond to Bootstrap list questions. Since many who ask IP-related questions on the list for the first time are, as mentioned, not familiar with these kinds of questions, let me provide a little proactive framing for future questions.
1 It is better to ask such questions here, or generally among IP-experienced business people, than to go straight to a patent attorney. Otherwise, (1) It is a self-fulfilling prediction that you'll be advised to file a patent application, and (2) that is a very expensive way to get basic or broad knowledge about IP.
2 When you are ready for an attorney, remember that not all attorneys are expert in the same things. Real estate attorneys should not do shareholder agreements, and divorce attorneys should not file patent applications. Even among patent attorneys, if the patent is important, you want someone with experience in the field and technology involved. And, you should ask about a patent attorneys experience in writing applications for inventors with commercialization strategies similar to your own. That assumes, or course, that you have a strategy when you walk in (hint, hint). So someone else's recommendation of a "great patent attorney" may not be what you really need.
3 IP includes Patents, Copyright, Trademark and Trade Secrets, which all have different purposes, effects and requirements. If you are not familiar with these and need some more basic information to choose a tactic or develop a strategy, those basic questions might be a better start than jumping into filing a patent.
4 If you believe that providing this background information about your company and your issue at hand will reveal too much proprietary information in the very open nature of the Bootstrap list, you may want to describe the area or nature of your question and invite people with experience or expertise in that area to contact you offline.
Don Jarrell (who is not an attorney) has worked with intellectual property from the business and Product Management perspective for (too) many years. In addition to operating a consulting practice in those areas, he is starting a software firm to provide a tool/system for performance metrics and analytics in the healthcare industry. He leads the Intellectual Property Initiative at Bootstrap Austin.
Friday, August 01, 2008
A Predictably Irrational Conversation with Dan Ariely-Live
Join Bootstrap Marketing for an evening of unpredictable food, rational conversation and a live interview with Dan Ariely, author of "Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions."
In his playful book, Dan Ariely offers some unexpected insights into how people behave when making decisions. Now is our chance to quiz him live on how to apply these simple concepts when marketing our products and services.
Join Bootstrap Marketing in person, and be a part of the conversation. Dan will be calling in for a one-on-one interview with Bootstrap Contributor Brian Massey, and then taking questions from you.
We'll be talking about:
- When "free" helps and when it doesn't
- How to use anchors to set price expectations
- How to present offers as choices and increase profitable sales
- How social norms, arousal, procrastination, and expectations affect our ability to help prospects make choices
Think of it as a one-night psychology course.
The price is right: bring a little something to eat and enough to share. Networking with central Texas business owners and marketers will precede and follow the event.
Tuesday, August 12
7:00pm to 9:00pm new time
The Home of Marcy Hoen
2015 Cullen Ave Unit B
Austin, TX 78757
Thursday, July 31, 2008
I must be CRAZY
As usual I found my self 1) running overtime about 45 minutes with the help of lots of questions from the listeners, and 2) yelling a lot, no one has ever tagged me as Mr. Congeniality. Many are appalled at my choices of adverbs and adjectives when talking about such things as VCs, bit-time CEOs, and corporate careers; but I get laughs and a few lights blink on (you can see it in their eyes) so it is not in done vain.
My son pointed out to me that my primary message is always the same; Francis Bacon was wrong, knowledge is not power, it is a mental holding pattern. Knowledge plus action is power, and in the end we do pretty much everything today for power. The difference between being an entremanure and an entrepreneur is action.
So again the theme is get off your ass and do something, customers will give the final idea so you can start with almost anything close. Only your personal insecurity retards the progress (it's called the "BOX", the one you are always trying to think out of). Just take it to the customer as soon as possible, they will straighten you out.
As short story before I close this testimony. I went to a presentation review for entrepreneurs a couple of months ago. I was a mentor along with a couple of other guys and we listened to a presentation by a couple of folks with an idea that they had poured $70k and a year into for software. They were looking for half a million and wanted us to comment on the presentation. They launched off on the idea, the pitch was all laid up on PowerPoint (which is only slightly better than morphine for numbing your mind). Five minutes into it I stopped it and asked - The Question..."What did the customers say?" The CEO told me that they had not presented this to any customers yet, only friends, family, and experts (someone who used to be call "Pert").
Well, I alienated everyone in the room with my usual question (delivered in my drill Sergeant's voice) . . . "What the F*** are you doing? Without customer feedback this is all a work of fiction! You made this all up, there is no reality in this presentation, only you dreams."
How can I comment on fiction in a real world? The other two mentors went on to talk about the cute slide show and how to make it cuter, they were corporate guys used to living in a cartoon. I got up and left. I don’t live in a fictional world (I may be delusional at times but not that day). They were too polite to deal with the truth, what a waste of everyone's time.
The truthache you have to have is the customer's reaction – will he give you a check for your idea when you can get it to work and what does "work" mean???
Nothing else counts!
Barry W Thornton is technologist, who organizes, manages and explains knowledge. Copyright Barry W Thornton 2008 all rights reserved
Wednesday, July 30, 2008
Old Masters and Young Geniuses
While this idea is comforting and liberating, as an experimental artist at the beginning of my career, it is also somewhat disconcerting. On one hand, I found it comforting to feel like I fit into some kind of framework. It was as if I was somehow finally granted the "permission" to work the way that I work. As an experimentalist, that kind of validation is no small thing. On the other hand however, I was also faced with a sense of impending doom with the idea that these insecurities that I harbor about my self as an artist are also an intrinsic part of being an experimentalist. David suggested that on average, most experimentalists tend to live a life of discontentment. As I stand here in the beginning stages of my career looking to the future, I can't help but feel a bit like Sisyphus rolling his rock up the mountain day after day only to watch it roll back down again.
Camus' message seems to be similar to Galenson's message to experimental artists, which is to embrace the way that you work and don't try to compete with conceptual artists. However, the problem that I run into with this notion is that of how to continue forward knowing that if I follow this way of thinking, that my "rock" will likely continue to roll back down the mountain perhaps indefinitely.
I think that while the theories presented in Old Masers and Young Geniuses are indeed worthy of consideration and undoubtedly thought provoking; they lack an investigation of lesser-known artists who are currently making their living as artists. That is to say that I think that the scope of Galenson's research may have been too narrow to provide a measuring stick for artists working today. I completely understand why he chose to focus on the artists mentioned in the book. It stands to reason that in order to collect quantitative data he would have to limit his focus to well known documented artists. I think that the theories that he presented are quite insightful and serve as an important jumping off point for anyone interested in understanding the creative process. However, I also think that these ideas should be interpreted with consideration of the limited scope of the research.
I suppose that in the end, I make art because I am compelled to do so regardless of monetary gain. While my intention is to generate an income with my work, I think the important thing to remember for now is to do the best I can with what I know. This book has added one more piece to the puzzle in that it has helped me define my goals just a little more. So, I will continue to push my "rock" up the mountain with the intention that one day it will stay at the top and perhaps even reach another peak that I cannot yet see.
Dara Chambers is a member of the Bootstrap Art Subgroup.
Friday, July 25, 2008
The Inner Journey
Objective reality asserts that there is a reality that is external to our thought and consciousness. We can perceive this reality through our senses and process it with our minds. This external reality exists independent of any of us and would still be here even if we weren't.
In an objective reality two journeys are taking place. The external journey of our idea/company with its interactions with the world and the internal journey which is our own personal growth as we learn what to do and how to do it. In this reality both journeys are important and, at any given time, one may be more important than the other.
OTOH, if we really exist in a subjective reality then there isn't any external journey at all! The journey is entirely an inner one. What we experience (what our venture experiences) is totally a product of our own thought. Hence, our venture's journey (the external journey) is identical to our inner journey, how we grow and learn and, more importantly, what we vision out.
So now let's do some odds (because physicists can't stay away from math). In the objective scenario the inner journey is at least half the journey. In the subjective scenario the inner journey is the whole journey.
If we take the fraction of both scenarios we see that the external journey only makes up 1/4 of the journey while the inner journey makes up 3/4 of it.
Let's assume that either scenario (objective or subjective) is equally probable. Then to get things right we should pay more attention to our inner journey because it is, most probably, the important part of the process.
Alex Cavalli is a physicist, technologist, actor, author, thinker, bootstrapper, speech/life coach and a whole lot of other things that you just don't want to know anything about. He leads the Bootstrap Inner Journey Initiative.
Monday, July 21, 2008
Don't Rock the Boat!
The internal entrepreneur's problem is changing the way the business thinks and acts. Like different DNA in a body, he (or she) is attacked as a fatal threat by the rest of the business unless he is shielded or camouflaged.
Protection or shielding does not work that well because it permits all the 'antibodies' to focus on a clear target. An example would be a CEO deciding that he needs to change the course of the business to grow, so he puts a spotlight on the group trying to change the way people think. Targeting, simple targeting. That spotlight makes it clear to all just who has to be wiped out to maintain the status quo. It is the guy rocking the boat that everyone can hate.
Camouflage on the other hand is surreptitious and a bit sneaky, doesn't attract a lot of attention and in the internal entrepreneur's case, lets him win converts, even gets the sympathy vote by the very people who will eventually be changed. By not putting the change mechanism in people's faces you offer a way to adapt that is not confrontational.
Traditionally new ways were developed in a skunk works, a place that was simply not visible where the Standard Operating Procedures could be tossed out and newness could happen. Problem is that skunkworking doesn't allow the newness to infect and drive the oldness to change, It leaves the oldness in isolation. You may get a neat new product but you don't necessarily get a new way of doing things.
The point is that the internal entrepreneur's job is really to adapt the organization to treat the customer in new ways. To do that his act must be visible and infectious to all but not threatening. Quite a trick, takes special guts, and in the end a love for both the business and customers. Because in today's marketplace this has to be a continuous process. Too bad GM can't figure this out.
Question is, can your company figure it out?
(1) DNA are the units of biological knowledge that set the pattern for the entity containing them, Memes are units of cultural knowledge the set the pattern for the way the entity thinks
Barry W Thornton is technologist, who organizes, manages and explains knowledge. Copyright Barry W Thornton 2008 all rights reserved
Thursday, July 17, 2008
VC Money in Bootstrap Companies
The Bootstrap Austin website talks about Plato's "Necessity, who is the mother of invention" and its bootstrap corollary "Constraint creates innovation". I don't think I appreciated how important the constraints are in helping a business find itself until now. Constraints are so amazingly important in helping businesses focus on the essence of what matters. Constraints force a bootstrap venture to communicate with customers and prospects to ensure that whatever is being delivered is something that is needed. The money that venture capital brings removes the constraints and my experience has been that when the constraint is removed, the focus on the customers' needs is replaced with either a shotgun approach ("lets see what sticks") or a focus on a perception of their needs.
There is a cultural shift that takes places after you raise venture money. First, it changes the mindset of employees who were part of the company before the venture money arrived. It's human nature that when money is scarce you are going to value it differently than when it is plentiful. Second, you begin to hire people who never knew the company as a bootstrap organization but only as a venture-backed one. The overall risk profile of the employee base shifts. Third, one of the benefits of taking venture capital is access to the resources of the venture capitalist who invested in the company. Among those resources are senior executives that will help you round out your team. Generally, the culture of those individuals are even further away from the culture of the company pre-VC.
When you add Silicon Valley to the mix, I believe all of these points blow up even more. The cost of living, the importance of speed often perceived as impatience, the sometimes incestuous relationships that maintain the cycle, and the search for the next Google are all factors that are magnified in Silicon Valley but are in no way exclusive to Silicon Valley.
Intellectually, I still believe you can apply bootstrap principals to venture backed companies but practically speaking, I believe it is very difficult to do so. Here are some random ideas, none of which have any proof of working, that I believe that would allow bootstrap companies to maintain some of the things that made them successful while still leveraging the catalyst that is money that venture capital provides.
- Don't announce internally or externally how much you raised or that you raised money at all. Reducing the number of people that are aware of your the company's bank balance is one way of artificially maintaining a culture. Of course, this is not realistic and comes with other consequences that I feel would outweigh the positives.
- Use budgets and targets to create artificial constraints. Controlling how much your sales team travels (e.g., 3 weeks per quarter) can create constraints that drives the right behavior. A sales person knowing that they have to make every travel day count will make sure that they prioritize the right customers (e.g., balancing the size of the deal with the likelyhood of closing the deal).
- Create a culture of capital efficiency. One such tactic is to be a hawk on expense reports (esp. the first 1-2 that a new employee submits).
- Lead by example. Employees will look to their leaders to determine acceptable behavior patterns. If their leaders are eating at Tavern on the Green and ordering $100 bottles of wine, the employees will think that is acceptable behavior.
- I'll reiterate the leadership point. If the founders and leaders of the company test their ideas by talking to customers, it will create a culture that the "Customer is #1". If the founders and leaders answer support questions regularly or at a minimum on occasion, it will create a culture that support is important.
- Use lore. I can not underestimate the power of stories in creating a company's culture. Every company has some stories the define it. Those stories course through the veins of the organization and every employee in the company knows those stories. When in an ambiguous situation, the employee will have the lore to fall back on to know how to handle that situation.
Neelan Choksi is currently enjoying a 4-6 month break from his efforts on the SpringSource management team, spending time with his pregnant wife and daughter, trying to get in shape, and knocking of the items on his "honey, to do" list.
Saturday, June 28, 2008
Necessity is the mother of Invention (and winning Chinese battles)
In 210 BC, a Chinese commander named Xiang Yu led his troops across the Yangtze River to attack the army of the Qin (Ch'in) dynasty. Pausing on the banks of the river for the night, his troops awakened in the morning to find, to their horror, that their ships were burning. They hurried to their feet to fight off the attackers, but soon discovered that it was Xiang Yu himself who had set their ships on fire, and that he had also ordered all the cooking pots crushed.
With their ships gone, the soldiers had no route of retreat. Winning was the only option. And win they did. 9 battles in a row before defeating the Qin forces.
This is similar to when a bootstrapper enters the Valley of Death and commits to their venture, but before they are making money and cash flow positive. They are forced to figure out how to make it work with what they've got. The timeline is not completely in their control.
We're always tempted to leave ourselves an escape route or path of retreat. And usually that's a good idea. But sometimes there aren't enough resources to mount the attack and cover the retreat. In order to be successful sometimes you have to commit the resources to what you believe in because the retreat option isn't acceptable. Sometimes once you head down a path there is just no turning back, so you might as well commit all of your resources to getting to the end.
When I was CEO of SKYLIST, this happened twice. We were growing and needed to shift focus based on customer demand and a rapidly changing market. Both of those times it was focused on eliminating unprofitable customers and focusing sales on specific types of opportunities. Each resulted in a temporary drop in revenue but strengthened the long term sustainability and profitability of the company.
When Datran Media bought SKYLIST, we went through the same exercise again. Each time the SKYLIST business came out stronger than before and had replaced the revenue with better customers within a year.
Each time it was the right thing to do and left us stronger than before, but each time we went into it kicking and screaming. Change is hard. When something works, we often get the urge to just do that over and over - well past the point where it stops working. It felt bad to move away from lines of business we had traditionally dominated.
But it was turning point for the company. Had we not burned the ships behind us, I'm not sure we would have survived and succeeded.
Joshua Baer's latest bootstrap startup is OtherInbox.com.
Reposted from Austinpreneur
Thursday, June 26, 2008
An Entrepreneur Who's Done It His Way
Rick Engel is a serial entrepreneur who currently owns Austin Java, Uncle Billy's, Little Woodrows and Paggi House. I love hearing entrepreneurs speak because there's always something about them that strikes a chord with me, regardless of what industry they have focused on. Listening to Rick was no different. What I enjoyed most was that he wasn't in a particular mold. Hard working...absolutely; focused on the customer...you bet. But most of all, he was real. Given where I am in my journey with entrepreneurship and trying to further understand what drives me, Rick's talk was just what the doctor ordered to help kick off my 4 month sabbatical from work.
As many of you know, I am a massive sports fan. I also hate inefficiency in every aspect of what I do. As such, "Moneyball" is one of my favorite books. If you are not familiar with "Moneyball", it is an exploration to understand why the Oakland A's with one of the smallest budgets in baseball has been so successful over the last decade. Baseball is fraught with inefficiencies, especially in player evaluation. Billy Beane, the General Manager of the Oakland A's, systematically explored and identified a number of those inefficiencies and exploited them. The sense I got is that Rick Engel does exactly the same thing in his specific industries. Not quite the classic entrepreneur with all of the right business school answers, Rick has identified some formulas for building great businesses and parlayed those formulas into a series of entrepreneurial successes in some of the toughest industries out there.
Like many entrepreneurs, Rick indicated he gets bored real quick. Some highlights from the path he has followed definitely support thist:
- As an undergrad, transferred to UCLA to chase a music career
- Jumped to the restaurant/bar industry
- Started 5+ different concept restaurants in Houston
- Even though he downplayed it in the talk, Rick sounded like he started the first online trading company
- Moved to Austin and again eventually re-entered the restaurant/bar business in Austin
- Created a management company for his restaurant endeavors and treated it like a profit center as he would with any of his other businesses.
- Now heading into the condo business
This is not to imply that Rick is not passionate about business. Spend 5 minutes talking to the man and his passion for his employees, customers, and businesses are very apparent and very real. I don't think that was made more obvious than in the Q&A session where Bootstrap Austin was treated to his deep knowledge. He rattled off details about traffic percentages, well thought out answers about short vs. long term solutions to his parking challenges, etc.
At SolarMetric, the company I helped found in 2001, I played a lot of different roles from accounting, marketing, general management, sales management, management of legals, business development, etc. I had key partners in the company, mostly in engineering and sales execution. In my first year at SpringSource (formerly Interface21), I operated in a very similar jack-of-all-trades manner. I really related to Rick Engel because of my background. Rick was a highly successful repeat entrepreneur who "did everything" himself in his earlier days in Houston. As he grew his career, he was able to get out of the "do everything" mentality by building a restaurant management business to manage his various restaurants and bars. Even as he built the management company, he went against the stream by treating it as a profit center rather than a pass-through company, the norm in the industry. By building the management company in his image and not taking the route that so many others have followed before him, Rick found a way of taking advantage of the scale that additional employees can bring while ensuring the elements of his personality and management style remained. Maybe there is hope for us-chronic do-it-all-ourselves types...one solution is to share the load but make sure the load is shared in a way that you are comfortable.
Another almost passing comment Rick mentioned really struck home to me: he feels like he has to be in control; he has to be a top level decision maker. He wants to know about every curve ball. The times when he hasn't been in charge (e.g., after he sold his trading company but stayed on), Rick hated the curve balls that were sent his way because he was not the final authority on the given topic. This is another thing I've struggled with a lot. I've really felt impotent in the past when I wasn't in control. So many times I wanted to tell employees that I would take care of them and make sure that I had their backs. When you aren't in charge, you aren't the decision maker and the best you can do is attempt to influence the actual decision-maker.
Rick had some great one-liners during the discussion:
"Don't ever have a partner. If you do have a partner, make it a silent partner."
"There are two really difficult things to do: 1) Partner with another entrepreneur - you'll have 2 different ways of doing the same thing. 2) partner with a non-entrepreneur - they can't relate."
"Don't ever get to a 50-50% situation on decisions unless you can get out of it."
"Bootstrap or die!" and this inspired Kyle Johnson to create a new Bootstrap Bumper Sticker in honor of Rick.The most interesting question posed to me by Business District's Jason Myers was whether I thought I could use some bootstrapping concepts in VC funded companies. My initial answer was a resounding, "Hell no!" but the more I've thought about it, the more I am not sure. I think another blog may be in order to explore this further.
My personal takeaway from this talk was the reminder that I have to be the entrepreneur that I am. There is only so much I can get from reading books, business school, and even other entrepreneurs. I can learn from others and incorporate things I learn from other sources into my version of the best entrepreneur that I can be, but it is my unique hero's (or goat's) journey to embark on.
Monday, June 23, 2008
Introducing Bootstrap Sustainability
That's a synthesis of what many emerging entrepreneurs have told me during the past several months we've been visioning the new charter for Bootstrap Sustainability. Guess what? Right now in your current business venture, there's plenty of "low hanging fruit" of changes you can make that will improve your company's impact as viewed from the lens of long-term stewardship.
What is Bootstrap Sustainability and how can it help my venture? Glad you asked. Bootstrap Sustainability is an official subgroup of Bootstrap Austin.
Bootstrap Sustainability exists to (1) identify businesses in sustainability that can be bootstrapped, (2) hook those ideas up with entrepreneurs and help nurture new and emerging bootstrap companies in the sustainability (or related) sector, and (3) provide education to the general Bootstrap Austin community.
We recently conducted a 6-hour workshop which brought 20 local thought leaders together in one room to help each other learn more about ourselves and the true nature of our current initiatives.
After the Bootstrap Bootcamp, the group rolled up their shirtsleeves and helped each other work through some of their most pressing immediate issues. In the spirit of the bootstrap community of bootstrappers helping each other perspectives and tactical advice were freely offered. By the end of the day, everybody was delighted with what we accomplished in the workshop and excited with where we are going individually and collectively.
Steve Harvey is the founder and CEO of the new bootstrap startup Cleantegrity, which exists to help emerging "cleantech" companies (such as solar, wind, energy efficiency, green building products, and new water-related technologies) bring more of the right products to market faster. For more discussion or information on Bootstrap Sustainability (or Cleantegrity, of course), please feel free to call Steve during the week at 512.878.6550 or send him an email.
Friday, June 20, 2008
Entrepreneurs Take Filmmaking to the Next Level
Wednesday, June 18, 2008
Brazlian Jiu Jitsu for Bootstrappers
I see a lot of similarities between BJJ and starting a business. The easiest way to get tapped out as a business is to turn away from your issues or challenges. As a bootstrapper, you don't have the luxury that investment capital affords. If you don't address your issues, you go out of business and the margin of error is razor thin. The faster you face your challenges, the faster you can address them and move on. If you think your business doesn't have issues, you're probably not looking hard enough
I started a return-on-investment consulting business, Wilson & Company, as a nights-and-weekends side job back in 2001. It was just me (not much of an "& Company") and I created ROI models in Excel and Visual Basic to help sales groups of technology companies sell their products. When your company is just you, it's easy to keep tabs on issues. You are the only tab. In 2005, I started Small World Labs, a social networking platform company that currently employs 27 people and has over 100 customers. When you combine the words "product" along with "employees" and "customers," things get more complex. And when things are more complex, there are more challenges to address.
Over Small World Labs' history we've faced the gamut of challenges as a company - from founder issues to quality control. Anytime I've seen an issue and not faced it, it has come back to bite us in the rear more severely. You only have 24 hours in the day so prioritization is a challenge in itself. However, deprioritizing an issue does not make it go away. Most times, it gets worse and you start to feel submission hold. That's when you absolutely have to face it or tap out.
Sometimes I've found I don't know how to solve an issue at first, but know it exists. Having a good network helps in these situations, from fellow entrepreneurs to business advisors. When you start to share your issues with trusted advisors, you often get a good, honest perspective on how to move forward. However, if you're the CEO, one way or another, it's incumbent on you to make sure your company is facing its opponents and not tapping out. Your employees, customers, partners, and investors depend on it.
Thursday, June 12, 2008
Bootstrap Mantra: "How are we different?" not "how are we cheaper?"
Unfortunately, most entrepreneurs do not create a detailed value message and pricing plan. They start with a product (or service, I'll use the word "product" to refer to either), or even a technology and then they seek customers for the product. Then they try to sell those potential customers on the benefits of the product. Often, this involves a comparison with a better known competitor: "It's like ACME's offering, but better, and it's cheaper."
Small companies often feel they need to be cheaper than established companies because they lack the brand value. However, something that's better and cheaper is suspicious. It may sound too good to be true. If there is a risk in going with a small company, how much cheaper does it have to be to mitigate that risk? How much cheaper would a car made by your college buddy in his garage have to be before you'd buy it to save money and use it to transport your kids? Lowering price is not an effective way to reduce risk in many situations, particularly when unknown firms try to compete with established companies.
If you have a good product, though, people will buy it and they will be happy that you made it cheaper than alternatives. They may also negotiate with you to get discounts and other concessions. Unfortunately for you, small price reductions can have a big impact on your financial and personal bottom line. If your business is running at 30% margins, a 10% price reduction means you need to sell 50% more volume just to break even. But at 50% more volume, you may need to hire more personnel, boost inventory, and make other costly investments.
Entrepreneurs tend to be driven people. They want to go the extra mile for their customers. So they make the product better, cheaper, and they throw in better service. This often means the owner spending more and more time supporting customers. Customer service is important, right? But the more service you provide, the more some customers will demand it. Before you know it, you're exhausted, frustrated, and you're having trouble growing the business. (For entrepreneurs who have not experienced this phenomenon, you can read about it in Michael Gerber's popular small business book, The E-Myth Revisited.)
Instead of starting your business with the idea of being cheaper, ask how you can be different. Differentiation is what provides the means to create and capture value. For example, for companies offering website design and support, it's hard to be cheaper than the global marketplace. But if you can offer turnkey solutions for specific industries that boost sales and use automation to send emails, saving time for your customers, you can charge more than commodity rates. Starbucks took a commodity offering and transformed it into a $4 per cup experience.
Not everyone wants $4 coffee, and not everyone is willing to pay a premium for website design. So even for small companies, having a range of offerings like "good/better/best" can be helpful. The important thing is that the different offerings cost you different amounts so even if you sell "good" you can still make money. For example, your low end product may not include personal support. Or you may have to buy in larger quantities to get a discount. The different offerings and price points allow you to capture more value under the demand curve than any single product and price point ever could. Appropriate "fences" prevent customers from downgrading. A common example is the Saturday night stay requirement for cheaper airline tickets. While nobody likes the airlines, we don't complain that movies are more expensive in the evening than the afternoon. We expect that if we want a higher level of service, we might pay more (or we might get a discount for accepting a lower level of service). Those customers who eat up all your time on "free" service might behave differently if they had to pay for the service. You might also be able to hire someone to do the service. Companies don't have supply problems, they have pricing problems.
You don't have to be different or better to everyone, just enough of a market for you to be successful. In fact, neglected parts of larger markets are great spaces for startups. Siebel Systems made a lot of money selling customer relationship management software to big companies, but they couldn't effectively sell to smaller businesses. Salesforce.com didn't start by competing with Siebel, they went where Siebel wasn't and created a more compelling offering for smaller customers.
By determining "how we're different" we differentiate ourselves from other market players, improve the value we capture, and increase the profitability of the business.
Reuben Swartz is the founder and president of Mimiran and author of Dollars and Sense: The Pricing Blog.
Tuesday, June 10, 2008
How to bootstrap your business by playing pinball
Ideation (and indeed Preideation and Matrix before it) is where entrepreneurs live before they launch their ventures. It's where they begin to self-examine, understanding why they're driven to launch a business, and begin to chart a path to being a successful entrepreneur. What usually isn't obvious is that it takes nearly as much work to be in ideation as it does to actually be an entrepreneur: there are challenges, both internal and external, that have to be overcome, not to mention constraints on time, resources, knowledge, and talent. Getting up to speed on this path is not easy at all! Otherwise there would be many more entrepreneurs around.
The Ideation Subgroup is where aspiring bootstrappers come to work through this process. And in helping them, I've discovered what I think is the perfect analogy for it all: playing pinball.
Think of your new business venture as the newest, coolest, flashiest pinball machine in the video arcade. As an aspiring pinball wizard, you're entranced and inspired, and so you plunk down some quarters and pull back the lever. And bam!, the ball goes straight down the shoot. No one said this was going to be easy. So you launch another ball, and it bounces around and wham! now you're getting some points. Cool! Another ball, and it bounces in to a bumper and goes in a totally new direction you never thought it could. And suddenly you're racking up more and more points. Sure, some of the balls you put into play don't go anywhere but straight down the shoot. But by continuing to make an investment (in quarters) and launching those balls into play, you will slowly but surely find yourself acquiring the mastery of your new domain...
So how does this relate to entrepreneurship? Ideation is just like pinball: you have to make an investment of time, energy, and of yourself. And you must launch many, many efforts along the way to learn the terrain of your business venture and to gain mastery over it. Absolutely some of those efforts will go nowhere (straight down the shoot) but many others will bounce around, moving you and your business in new directions that will help you achieve success.
So the bottom line is: get some balls in play. And a roll of quarters. You're going to need them on your way to becoming a successful, bootstrap entrepreneur.
Edward Cruz is the founder of Bootstrap Company Melior Technologies, and his first product is Molecular Thinking.
Monday, June 09, 2008
Total Leadership
Heather McKissick (right) the new Executive Director of Leadership Austin, kicked off the session describing her organization's unique charter in the Austin community: to ignite passion and provide support for those who wish to serve their community. I introduced Bootstrap's unique mission to support entrepreneurs through the Bootstrap Model of entrepreneurship.
Phyllis Blees, who leads the Bootstrap Book Club (and FLOW - see John Mackey's upcoming talk) organized the event. Bootstrap Contributor Kyle Johnson, founder of Bumperactive, designed a unique bookmark featuring the Bootstrap and LA logos. Kyle also designed the Bootstrap Bumper Stickers and my t-shirt features the innovative Valley of Death bumper sticker.
Stew riveted the audience with this unique challenge: what if you could not just balance life's seemingly competing aspects of community, work, home and self, but arrange them so they reinforce and amplify each other? Not only an intriguing proposition, but wholly achievable with the right mindset and approach! I am personally very excited as Total Leadership beautifully reinforces youplusU, the third model I evangelize. Stew is one of the few leaders in the business community (Jim Collins, Roger Martin and John Mackey being others) who voices the notion that seeming dualities are to be integrated, not compromised. I was therefore also very glad to add Stew's book to my uplusyou reading list.
Please visit the Total Leadership website to learn more about this innovative and compelling model!
The BootRap Podcast will soon feature Stew's talk.
Thursday, June 05, 2008
The Accidental Licensor
Bijoy was telling me about the many business collaborations he is involved in through Bootstrap. Most of these partnerships hinge on a revenue sharing agreement. Bijoy owns the content, allows the partner to use the content to create and sell a product, and he shares a portion of the revenue.
Bijoy is in the licensing business, and didn't even know it! He has built valuable Intellectual Property that others are willing to pay to use and embed in their products. His revenue sharing model is the equivalent of a royalty license agreement. For every item sold, Bijoy receives a percent of net sales.
Now the fun part.
Bijoy was complaining that he had a difficult time tracking the sales results of his growing list of partners. He and his "Licensees" had been using email and spreadsheets to keep tabs on sales and payments owed. As a result, there was confusion, delays in reporting, and many partners were way behind on their payments.
It was like a fastball right over the plate for RoyaltyZone.
Luckily, Bijoy had his laptop with him. We created a RoyaltyZone account and published a license agreement for one of his licensees in a matter of minutes. Now Bootstrap has a way to keep everyone on the same page regarding how, what, and when reports and payments are due. Bijoy has a dashboard view of all his partners, what they've sold, what they've paid, and what they owe.
The light bulb went off! Ideas started flying around new ways to license the Bootstrap brand and IP, now that there was a tool in place to track performance and payment.
Welcome to the licensing business, Bijoy! I wonder how many other accidental licensors are out there...
-----------------
Lou Ellman is the Founder and CEO of the bootstrap startup RoyaltyZone
Sunday, June 01, 2008
Austin, the Experience City?
The chamber has launched a new initiative, Austin Human Capital for its current external marketing efforts. The website also features short video vignettes featuring various Austinites including myself.
GSD&M has done 'Idea City' which resonates quite a bit as Austin is a fertile place for new ideas to be born because of the acceptance and openness that Richard Florida discussed in his book, Rise of the Creative Class. Unfortunately, due to it now being directly associated with GSD&M, it cannot be adopted by the city as a whole. The Keep Austin Weird movement is also a part of this ongoing encouragement towards Florida's "Tolerance," but it is at best an internal call to the city's residents rather than an external branding exercise.
And we have the Live Music Capital of the World, adopted by the City of Austin in 1991.
I've always thought Austin is a perfect entrepreneurship, and particularly bootstrap entrepreneurship due all the above factors coupled with its low cost of living.
Still, none of these themes captures the overall essence. Perhaps an idea forwarded by Joe Pine in 1999 might provide that encompassing theme: the Experience Economy.
Starting, of course, with the city itself and all the things we already enjoy: nature, the live music scene, etc. Our attitude, which fosters openness and acceptance means that we can all create our own experiences within the city. A brief check of Austin's various event calendars, such as Holly's Hot Happenings, or the Austin Chronicle reveals an almost infinite array of events happening on any given day. But beyond that, the quintessential Austin companies and organizations create experiences for the customers and constituents:
- Whole Foods Market - turns grocery shopping into an experience
- RunTex - making getting fit into an experience through weekend races and an involved running community
- Alamo Drafthouse - beer, food, film, events!
- Amy's Ice Cream - watch as your ice cream gets made with crushins and goodies
- Austin City Limits - 3-day music festival at Zilker Park
- SXSW - Interactive, Music & Film Conference held at the Convention Center and all over town. Indeed, the parties are considered just as important (if not more!) than the conference content
- The Long Center - integrated approach to entertainment with open and closed space and events
- Leadership Austin - immerses participants in the city through various programs and ongoing events and shows them how they can make a difference
- Craig Nadel, Groove Labs
- Tim Hayden, Game Plan Marketing
- Gary Hoover, Road Story
- Jason Myers, Interactive Austin and other conferences
- Cindy Lo, Red Velvet Events - creating unique events for all occasions
- Marcy Hoen, Austin Art Start - new ways to experience art and artists
- Jesse Bloom, Ecstatic Cuisine - integrated food experiences
- Tania Cowher, Celeb4aDay - personal paparrazi for hire
- Chris Hyams, BSide - powers film festivals including the recent Bootstrap Film Fest
- Edward Cruz, Molecular Thinking, interactive brainstorming
- Mark Smith, Mikons - creates connection during events using Mikon stickers
- Tom Baum: 40-day homeless immersion project
One might even argue that Bootstrap Austin turns entrepreneurship into an experience where we make friends, help each other, learn along the way and have fun doing it.
It does seem that it would be beneficial to brand Austin in an encompassing way that not only honors what we've already done, but captures the essence.
Let's explore the question of the together at the Experience City website. If we are indeed an experience city, what can we do to get better at being one and how will we share this with the rest of the world?
Wednesday, May 28, 2008
Bootstrap Film Fest: Projecting Beyond the 'Bootstrapping' Buzz
"Bootstrapping" has become a buzz word that is thrown around loosely to sound cool. But, what does it mean? Some use 'bootstrapping' to describe self funding or micro-budgeting. At best, that is the least interesting way to define 'bootstrapping'. Bootstrapping is so much more. It is not about sizing our project by the size of your wallet. It is about using constraints to create something entirely new and unique to you.
Bootstrap Film Fest will wake entrepreneurs up to a whole new world of possibilities. Tickets, trailers and more available at BSide, a Bootstrap member company.
Tuesday, May 27, 2008
Right Action, Right Time for Funding
At the Bootstrap Growth Subgroup meeting in April, two knowledgeable local executives presented their experience and tips on Funding....
Michael Wilson, founder and CEO of Small World Labs
Our speakers' experiences spanned the gamut in why, how, and the lessons learned in getting investors to pony-up for the growth of their venture. Three wise principles stand out:
- Proceed with the end in mind
- Go for the money before you need it
- Choose your investors wisely
It takes a very long time to get investment money. The tasks involve: getting the connections; establishing relationships; negotiating the terms; and, working full focused to move things through. Not only do these steps occur over time, during this time you still have your duties in your business and could be looking at some very long days. Start this process way before you're ready for the money. The day you wake up and decide you need funding, you will be thankful that you started conversations in the right circles - long before.
Your investors become your left-hand, your shadow, and your conscience. You want to know well about their motives, their expectations, and their interests in your company because when you take their money, you become accountable to them.
When considering investment funding for your business, keep in mind right action right time. The implications of this funding will vary markedly, depending on the stage of your business. For example, if your venture is in Ideation, your investors are likely to become your bosses and you become an employee who can then be fired. When your venture is beyond the VoD and in Growth, you are likely to have more influence in creating the terms of that funding and control in the business afterward.
Nancy Schill, founder, Executive Intelligent Coaching and co-lead, Growth Subgroup
Monday, May 26, 2008
Bootstrapping is Effectual, not Causal
With only 8 pages of text, it was a quick read. While the article doesn't talk about bootstrapping specifically, it immediately resonates with any true bootstrapper and has a lot in common with Demo, Sell, Build.
Saras explains the "common sense" model of causal reasoning, where you first select a goal, come up with a strategy to achieve the plan, acquire the necessary resources, and finally execute on the plan. This sounds perfectly logical and is the way that many people go about planning a new business.
But then she defines effectual reasoning, where you start by evaluating the resources you have and figuring out what you can do with them. What are you excited about? What skills do you have? What relationships can you leverage to your advantage? Once you have a place to start, get to market quickly and learn from your customers. Then start the process over now that you have more information.
In comparison, causal reasoning seems rigid and inflexible. Effectual reasoning is fast to start, low risk to experiment with and has faster iterations. By getting to market quickly and incorporating user feedback, effectual reasoning is more likely to produce the best product and better able to respond to a rapidly changing marketplace. Too often with causal reasoning, it takes so long to get to market that the market changes before you get there.
When I started SKYLIST at Carnegie Mellon, I didn't have some grand plan - I mostly just did things that people offered to pay me to do. I got into email hosting because I was rejected for the WebSTAR beta program but was accepted for the ListSTAR beta program. My first customers were all relationships that I developed while working with ListSTAR at StarNine. I used the PowerMac 7100 that my parents bought me for college to host them and I stuck it on the school network in my dorm room.
Starting UnsubCentral was a similar story. I wasn't planning on starting a new company. The CAN-SPAM law was passed in December 2003 and the opportunity presented itself. I didn't spend a lot of time researching the market - I just dove in and started building it and we launched the product in January. I thought all our customers would be other email service providers like SKYLIST - because that was what I knew the best. But it turns out that our primary customer base was advertisers because that's who is directly responsible under the law. Fortunately we built the right product and just had to refocus our sales efforts on the right customer.
And my current startup, OtherInbox, is no exception. I looked around at the problems with my own email that I want to solve. I leveraged more than a decade of experience working with email marketing in designing the initial solution. I taught myself Ruby On Rails and built a demo myself. Then I started using it.
After convincing myself that I was on the right track, I partnered with a friend from Carnegie Mellon to start building a version that could support multiple users. I recruited some of my close friends as beta testers. Right now we're learning more every day about how people use it and we're iterating until we have it right.
I'm not saying we won't ever take an investment. In fact its very likely that we'll need to raise money at some point in order to ramp up customer acquisition or to expand internationally. But the longer we can put it off, the more we'll understand exactly what to do with the money we raise. The more we understand our customers and our model, the less equity we'll have to give up.
Joshua Baer's latest bootstrap startup is OtherInbox.com.
Reposted from Austinpreneur
